...of Making Decisions and Standing by Them

Talk It Out:
When Other People Don't Understand Your Simple Lifestyle

 

"My question relates to how to give good answer to statements from fellow believers such as, ‘No one would have any jobs if everyone lived like you,’ (meaning living very frugally and sacrificially so that resources can be shared with those who have much less, both locally and globally), or ‘What is so bad about living a luxurious lifestyle? I worked for everything.’ Any input on how to handle these kinds of comments would be helpful." ~ Martie


Responses:

 
"Martie, you should read the Book of Proverbs in the Old Testament any time the naysayers' comments get under your skin. It has a lot of wisdom in it -- especially about the importance of being wise and not being foolish and/or lazy. There might even be a verse or two in there you could memorize and quote to someone should circumstances warrant.
 
 Or, you can remain silent and just walk away from the verbal assault. A good answer is sometimes silent.
 
Realize  that you don't know these fellow believers' whole financial story. For all we know, they could be on the verge of bankruptcy. Perhaps their comments stem from jealousy (i.e., they envy your discipline and common sense), or perhaps it's because they are uncomfortable and feel a lot of guilt about their debt-ridden lifestyle. You are not obligated to defend your lifestyle of simplicity to people who may not realize it is a gift of the Spirit.
 
Time is often life's great teacher, and it can humble some of the most vocal critics in the church and community. I know that when I was growing up, people made snide remarks about the fact my mother worked outside the home. The very ones with the rudest comments later had to borrow money for their kids to attend college. Meanwhile, I went to a four-year university --  debt-free, thanks to my mother, who worked and saved and sacrificed for me.
 
Likewise, it's possible that some years down the road, the people who are most critical of you will meet with their 'comeuppence' -- not from you, Martie, but by financial circumstances they are creating for themselves right now. 
 
You are not obligated to defend yourselves to such people! Again, a good answer is sometimes silent.
 
It's also important to be a humble and gracious Christian. We should try not to take a 'holier-than-thou' stance to anyone who lives in a bigger home or drives a newer car lest he or she thinks we are the ones who are jealous.
 
 Remember, Jesus loved rich and poor alike, and He was a great teacher of Prosperity as well as Salvation." ~ Lynn

 



"I’m employed by a dentist, and all the other employees usually order out for lunch and spend money much more freely than I do.

At my previous office, I felt that I was looked down on for this, and my feelings were a little bit hurt when they stopped even asking me to go out to eat with them.

I am working fewer hours at my new office, so until December will be making a somewhat less than I was at my old job.  My co-workers know that, and also that right now my goal is to get all my bills paid off.  I still order out occasionally, but when I don’t, they know why, and it does not seem to be an issue.

I am comfortable with my choices, and that may be the difference. I let everyone know what my priorities are, and I don’t feel that I need to belabor the point or continue to explain why I don’t spend money. 

I also think it is great when someone else has the finances and chooses to purchase something wonderful for themselves. There are certain things I do for myself, too, such a visiting our kids and our granddaughter. That is one expense I will never cut!" ~ Brenda


"Everyone has their own priorities in life. I think it is commendable that you have made others your priority rather than yourself. That’s not to say you are denying yourself; you’re just not investing in things that you don’t really need. There will always be those less fortunate who need some help – people with disabilities or health issues, those who were born into a difficult life and need an extra boost to make it, or those who just made some bad decisions and need a little assistance to get back on their feet. Contributing to reputable organizations doesn’t mean you are helping to keep people unemployed. You’re choosing not to live excessively so that others also have a chance to thrive. " ~ Jeanette


 
"At the age of 25, I quit my teaching job to become a stay-at-home wife. Eight years later, I'm still at home, and we have no children. This is like some sort of social taboo because people just assume that if I have no children, I should be in the workforce.
 
I simply tell people that this is what works for us. My being at home allows us to live a fairly stress-free life. No, we can't afford all the things we would be able to if I were bringing in a second income, but on the flip side, our house is in order, our meals are home-cooked, and we are both able to relax in the evenings rather than doing chores that weren't done because we were at the office all day. 
 
As for those who want to know what's wrong with luxurious living--there's not a thing wrong with it, as long as you can afford it.  But eschewing that lifestyle myself doesn't mean I'm passing judgment on those who live that way. We all have choices to make in life, and mine happens to be the choice that works best for us.  Also, what people don't seem to realize is that by living frugally, it helps free up what money we do have to give to others. Our charitable giving isn't as much as what we gave from two incomes, but it's still pretty substantial, and according to many polls, we're giving more than the general public. I don't say that to toot my own horn, but just to offer perspective. Frugal living doesn't have to mean stingy living. 
 
As an aside, I can't even begin to tell you how many of my husband's co-workers have looked at him enviously and said they wished their wives stayed home." ~ Anne Marie

"This is an interesting question. I am very frugal and just about everything I own is secondhand. If other people were as careful I would not be able to buy their stuff from garage sales and thrift shops. So in a way I feel dependent on the wasteful people." ~ Julia in UK


"I found real freedom when I realized I can’t 'fix' other people, especially when it comes to money. As for the folks who want to say our economy would collapse if we didn’t all go out and buy something, I seriously doubt we’ll ever see that happen. For every one person who likes to live within their means, there are hundreds who honestly believe that maxed-out credit cards are some sort of constitutional right. As for the folks who justify their spending by saying they earn it, good for them – but I can’t afford to live like that. I have a friend who readily admits that she leases automobiles so she can drive newer, nicer vehicles more cheaply than buying them on installments. While I think she’s crazy, she thinks I’m crazy for opting to pay cash for an older vehicle rather than have any payments. Be true to yourself. If you are making people prickly, it’s probably because they secretly wish they had more discipline and self-control." ~ Cindy 


"Well, honestly I really do not discuss my finances with people so I never have to defend them.  But at times I will share a few 'secrets' on how to live more simply and I do it without showing any embarrassment at all!  I think people are amazed that someone as 'modern' and educated would choose to make choices so different from the mainstream. I do like to casually mention some interesting websites, such as Counting the Cost which I hope my friends might decide to review.  But everything in life comes down to choices. If someone mentions to me that I am too frugal etc., I just smile and say that I am happy with my daily decisions. I will admit that in the workplace it is difficult to share frugal tips because people are so judgmental and assume that you might be a little 'weird.'  That can actually hinder your progress or position within a working situation. I refrain from talking about my personal financial life completely. That is too bad because I think more of us who are accepting frugality as a lifestyle are in great positions to help those who are struggling. It is almost like we are in a secret society of people who 'get the big picture.' If I really get to know someone very well I will opt to share some ideas.  Sometimes you feel that it is not politically correct to discuss how you really feel about our economy. That is the most alarming problem as I see it between those of us who are living simply and the vast majority of people who are gambling with their financial future. My husband and I very recently relocated to another state, retired and are living a wonderful life having paid cash for our home. Many of our friends/colleagues are simply stunned that we could do this before 60 years old!  They have no concept that this is a possibility....and certainly not for them even in the near future. That is too bad." ~ Janice

"To the question at hand, when people approach you with this question tell them there is nothing wrong with that as long as they are doing it with respect to themselves, others, the community and environment. The path you chose is different. It blows me away as to how many 'stones' we all are guilty of casting. The other quicker question that you may ask  (I have asked this one...a lot) with a kind tone is, 'Why do you care or/ mind?' You have to ask this very direct question with sincerity and non-flippantly or all is lost. So much of the time in this economy the question of, 'What's so bad' is asked out of curiosity and oftentimes fear because the person asking is in a spot. I live in the thick of this. We live where we live because the schools are great, and it's safe. We live somewhat differently from a majority of our neighbors and friends. We don't appear any different--but we sleep much more soundly than most around us because we won't surrender to putting ourselves in a perilous position for the sake of instant gratification. Sorry I'm so long-winded! Hope this helps. Have a great day." ~ Mollie 

 

Editor's Note: Thanks to these subscribers for taking the time to respond.

Sign up for Counting the Cost
a free twice-a-month email newsletter filled with ideas, insights and inspirations for living each day to the fullest. 

Email address:

Subscribe Unsubscribe

Google
 
Web     CountingtheCost.com

Home    Products and Resources     Speaking Engagements    Nancy's Itinerary  
Creative Frugality
     Talk It Out     Abundant Living    Readers' Input      Advertising Information      
National Creative Frugality Week
    Media Mentions and Publicity     Support This Site