...of Maintaining Good Relationships

Talk It Out:
Dealing with Overzealous Givers

 

"We are friends with a family who are in a higher income bracket than we are. They are very down-to-earth and also very generous in their gifts to us. While we usually spend less than $10 on a gift for their child, they usually spend $30-50 on gifts for our children’s birthdays, Christmas, etc. I appreciate their kindness but feel awkward about it. Do you have suggestions for handling this situation diplomatically?" ~ Alice


Responses:

 
"Alice – I have a very similar situation. The best advice you can get: Continue to be gracious and thankful. Have the kids write personal thank you notes. Let the givers know how much the gift was appreciated and loved!

There is no rule that says we have to give back as much or more than we receive. This family obviously cares for you and your family and just because they are in a financial bracket that allows them to be bigger ‘givers’ you shouldn’t have a competition. Don’t feel guilty. That is not what GIFTS are meant to do and shouldn’t be used in that way. If they are 'down to earth,' they also appreciate the gifts back. 

To assuage your feelings of awkwardness or inadequacy, is there something your family can offer the child (non-monetarily) that would be just as special? Camping, family day out picnic, kite building & then flying, art day, funky dress up day walking around the mall with photos (think Halloween in June), library day, skating, fishing, whatever – you can always plant the memories that children will remember long after the gift is gone. Take lots of photos and create scrapbook pages just for the kids. The adage, 'It’s the thought that counts,'  is the truth.  Relax and enjoy each and every blessing." ~ Denise in Tennessee


 
"I think you should just talk lovingly, openly and honestly with your friends about this issue. We too have very close friends who have an income way above ours, and enjoy the finer things in life. They asked us to go on holiday with them, and we refused, saying that whilst we really appreciated their offer, we couldn't possibly afford the holiday that they were suggesting, and would only feel comfortable if we could pay our way. They fully understood this, respected our decision, and made a strong statement that they really valued our friendship, not our financial status. Since then they have also been more sensitive on the gift-giving front. I have another acquaintance who is vastly wealthy, far beyond the means of most of us, and she has confided in how lonely she is at home with three small children because 'ordinary' people feel so uncomfortable around her, although she does not flaunt her money. It really gave me food for thought about what we value in people and friendships. I'm sure your friends, if they are friends worth having, love you for who you are, not what you have, and  would be horrified if they thought their generosity was making you feel uncomfortable. Talk it over with them before it becomes a big issue; that's my advice." ~ Dessie

 


 
"We've encountered this, also.  One way that has helped us is to mention ahead of time, 'We have a little something to give to your son for Christmas,' prior to getting together when you know gifts will be exchanged.  It conveys to them ahead of time that while we want to give their child something to show our love, it's not a huge gift.  We did this for this past Christmas and it worked very well. Their gifts to our children were much less costly than in the past and we were much more comfortable with the exchange. ~ Jen

 
"In my opinion, there is no problem here. You give what you can and you give from your heart as do your friends. Doubtless they understand that you are in a different situation than they are, but they still give gifts according to what they want to give you and not according to what they will receive in return. Part of the gift giving process is learning how to receive graciously. Making them feel like they are giving too much or that you are uncomfortable with their heartfelt gift giving is not receiving graciously. It can be difficult to accept that others have means beyond our own. But gift giving is about the giver as much as the receiver. Take joy in the blessings that your hearts are able to bestow on each other and on each others' children and try not to worry about the price tag of those blessings." ~ Stephanie


"What a prime example of a time when it may be beneficial to just allow yourself to be filled with gratitude. Avoid focusing on 'fair and balanced' and just be grateful for your friends. Don't allow pride to overrule you. Friendship is not about keeping score. Do not deprive them of the blessing of being generous givers. Receive with a grateful heart. And look for opportunities to give generously (whatever that looks like for your family) to others." ~ Sarah

"Suggest to them that they give the difference in cost to a charitable organization that helps children, such as www.smiletrain.org ." ~ LMB


"Oh, this is SO relavant to my life right now! My husband's sister and brother-in-law live in a million dollar home, drive expensive cars, and wear name-brand clothes. They have 3 kids, 19, 16, and 13. Every year we do Christmas boxes (think Operation Christmas Child) for all the kids in the family. Now, the boxes aren't exactly filled with discounted items - a good estimated value per box is $100-$200 each. My husband and I had a long conversation after the holidays about the boxes. Apparently his sister called and said her kids don't like the gifts we send and we shouldn't waste our money anymore. My heart was broken, because Christmas for me is all about giving, not receiving. So, Alice, what do you say? 'Thank you for your thoughtfulness,' because gifts shouldn't be appraised. They should be enjoyed without strings. Don't do your friends a disservice; they clearly love you and want to just see that big smile when you receive their gift. And, if they're that rare person that is just trying to one-up you, you're still the beneficiary, right?" ~ Emily in Ohio



"We have bowed out of giving gifts to anyone our age for Christmas. We only give to the nieces and nephews on my husband's side of the family. We give a small gift to my parents. We are all about just getting together to have fun; it's not about the gifts. But for my husband's sister and sister-in-law, that's a different story. They are a little extravagant with the gifts. It's a little awkward at times, but we give what we can afford. I can't compete with people who are all about the money.
 
We are really broke right now. I used to be willing to spend about $10 for a child's birthday present if one of my kids was invited to a party. Now I look for gifts when they are on clearance and put stuff away in my closet, things on sale for $5 or less. Then when they are invited to a birthday party, they can pick out something in my closet, or I give them $5 toward a gift if they want to purchase something. I was proud of my daughter for the great gift she got her friend at Michael's the other day. I gave her $5 budget, she came in at 4.93 and felt good about what she picked out. There is a difference between being cheap and being frugal." ~ Diana

"We are similarly blessed in our life with friends who have a greater source of income than we. We try to give from our hearts when we give and we don't go beyond what our income level allows...but probably the greatest learning experience involved in our friendship with this family has been how to accept the blessing of their gifts with a heartfelt thank you and without comparisons. This is something God has dealt with me about this past year. My friends are wonderful people and let us know daily how much we mean to them...They are a blessing God put in my life and their gifts are blessings as well." ~ Terri aka PennyAnnPoundwise


"I too have been in Alice's position, with a millionaire friend who was generous. I'm sure her friends are well aware of Alice's situation and are giving according to their means, and as they give to their other friends. Alice is doing the same thing, giving according to her means. What is to feel awkward about? Only the fact that she is measuring the  price of the gift, which if she were on the other side of the exchange, surely she would be ashamed to do. We all give according to our means. If people measure the worth of the gifts I give, I reconsider whether that person should be in my life." ~ Ellen


Editor's Note: Thanks to these subscribers for taking the time to respond.

Sign up for Counting the Cost
a free twice-a-month email newsletter filled with ideas, insights and inspirations for living each day to the fullest. 

Email address:

Subscribe Unsubscribe

Google
 
Web     CountingtheCost.com

Home    Products and Resources     Speaking Engagements    Nancy's Itinerary  
Creative Frugality
     Talk It Out     Abundant Living    Readers' Input      Advertising Information      
National Creative Frugality Week
    Media Mentions and Publicity     Support This Site