...of Managing Your Money with a  Conscience

Talk It Out:
Boycotting the Big Boys


What do you do when you learn that one of your favorite retail giants supports causes which you find objectionable? That was the question one of our readers submitted just the other day. Sue wrote to ask if I was aware that a major discount chain has formed a partnership with a liberal political group. Sue’s comments included these questions:

"My family has elected to not shop at stores owned by this corporation because of these actions. I must say that it really can be a financial burden to do this. However, some of our stands must involve sacrifice…We've chosen not to compromise. Someone told me that other large corporations probably are supporting things we wouldn't like in their charitable contributions. Perhaps, but this is one I do know about so what are my obligations as a Christian? I would appreciate your offering some suggestions on savings techniques. I am already using our grocery chain ads and buying generic brands and on sale items and feel I am saving. Other tips will be most appreciated too. Where would be some good sources for buying vitamins?" ~ Sue

Rather than focusing the discussion on this particular retailer, this "Talk It Out" question addressed the topic of boycotting in general: 

Have you ever chosen to boycott a big corporation because of policies with which you didn’t agree? Did your decision to boycott involve financial sacrifice on your part? If so, how did you deal with this? Do you have any specific suggestions to help Sue save money -- suggestions that don’t involve shopping at one of the biggest discount chains in the country? Also, since she mentioned vitamins specifically, do you know of any good sources for saving on vitamin products?


Responses:

"We live in a capitalist society that is highly consumer-driven. Boycotting is really the only way an individual can send a clear message that a decision made at the corporate level violates a particular customer's values. We all have choices and no store is indispensable! This is the American way. If a store does not meet our needs, we will find one that does. This is especially true over the last few years when so many companies have used highly sexual advertising to sell clothing to minors. It is indeed difficult because so many companies have more or less 'jumped on the bandwagon.' A real boycott is only effective if you notify the company that you are no longer shopping with them and give a reason. 

Shopping at 'big box' stores can be deceiving on price. I would suggest 'secondary markets' such as thrift stores, antique shops, discounters and some drug stores often have good deals on many items. I have purchased vitamins at drug stores early in January when there are many sales. I usually stock up at this time." ~ Janice


"I have boycotted this same retailer for one year as of this month. I do not miss it one bit! I find everything I need at my local grocery/hardware/drug stores just fine. I decided to do this because of the way the company treats their employees. I have never worked for them, but I did work for several years for the largest greeting card company in the US, who has the card/party departments in all these stores. I became acquainted with a number of their employees and saw the everyday behind the scenes happenings at several of their stores in my area, which convinced me to never spend another dime of my money at that chain again. Sometimes you just have to speak up about what you think is wrong and take action." ~ Janice


"Yes, I joined a company called Quixtar because of their high morals. Not only do they deliver my purchases to my house, but I also get money back at the end of the month if I spend a certain amount. Anyway, I hope that helps." ~ Anonymous


"I, too, am not shopping at this large retailer. I have been doing most of my shopping at Winn Dixie, Dollar General, and Fred's.  Big Lots also has good prices on groceries.  I like to shop there because they have unusual food products as well as common ones.  Dollar General has really good prices on drugs, as does Fred's.  We also have 2 bulk suppliers here for restaurants that are open to the public.  You have to watch their prices, because it can sometimes be cheaper at the dollar stores, but overall they have good prices.  Oh, we have an independent grocer that I recently went to, and noticed a lot of their prices were cheaper than the national store." ~ Beverly Grace


"I am not sure I have any additional tips for Sue, but she can know that she is not alone in this stand.  Almost a year ago, my husband and I decided to boycott 2 of the major retailers for similar reasons. I can honestly say that I have not missed them as much as I thought I would and that our budget has not suffered. That said, it takes some work. I watch for sales and stock up on various items, clip coupons and use cheaper brands (usually store brands).  Also, this has forced me to really think about my purchases. Do I need the item? If so, how much do I need?  I honestly think I buy less than I did. Certainly not going to a large store where I can find it all cuts down on impulse shopping and those extras that end up in the cart. That has been a blessing. Our biggest challenge has been with clothing items. We purchased socks, underwear, jeans etc. there and the prices are much cheaper than other retailers. But again, we have approached this in a similar way: watching for sales and discount coupons etc.  Sue wondered what her responsibility as a Christian is concerning these retailers and how they spend her money. I believe that is something each husband and wife have to decide for themselves.  I certainly encourage anyone who is wondering about this to pray and let the Lord lead.  My husband and I felt God was calling us to be better stewards of His money in several ways and one was to not support businesses that promoted or supported certain causes. I am also sure that a portion of the money we spend still goes to things we wouldn't personally support.  It is impossible for us to know where all of our money goes once it has been spent. But like Sue and her husband, we are dealing with what we do know." ~ Barb


"I have made the decision to boycott stores and manufacturers when their business practices/choices have clashed with my own. The first thing I do is to contact that company so they know that I am taking my business elsewhere. (They are so big that they won't notice my money going elsewhere, but the advance notice may affect future decisions -- I hope.)

 I have purchased vehicles that I wouldn't normally consider, and did so due to the fact that my normal manufacturer had gone 'anti-traditional family.' That has turned out to be a great decision as my car gets twice (44 vs 23) the miles-per-gallon of my old car.

 I have taken some of my 'major retailer' business to local merchants. I have just started getting my vitamins at Aldi's (the % look good). I'm going to the major retailer's biggest competitor for many of my other needs, including prescriptions. Am I saving as much? Maybe. I find myself doing less impulse buying. However, even if I am spending a little more, I am showing my children that morality and values are worth more than a few dollars." ~ Diana in Batavia, NY


"The big retailer Sue is boycotting is one of the worst places to shop. They don't pay their clerks a living wage and in some states they have to sign up for benefits from welfare. Cheapest isn't always best, when you figure out who isn't being paid enough for working." ~ Martha


"We, too, have decided to boycott this large corporation. There have been times in the past where we have chosen to not shop at other stores until something has changed as well. This is just something that we feel that we must do. Normally, I'm not much into boycotting because I don't feel like my small contribution amounts to much. But in this case, a decent sum of money goes out each month, and we will be spending it elsewhere. (And there is more than one reason for us to decide to boycott.) In our town, we only have one large grocery store, a small discount grocery store and a supercenter for this corporation. This is what we're doing. Once a week, I drive to another town for church and on a different day we drive into that town to clean our church. So I shop at other department stores when I'm out. I'm watching the sales closely and have decided to buy a little extra if there is a good sale, because I will not have the convenience of just stopping in to the local store. You know what? It allows me to think through purchases and keeps me from making unnecessary trips to the store. I didn't spend any more this month on things that I would have spent at the boycotted store because of careful  planning. It CAN be done, and if it's something important to you, there's a way to get around the convenience of things." ~ Leslie


" I, too, have decided to boycott one of the nation's largest discount retailers lately due to some corporate decisions they have made recently. And this decision was hard for me. I did a large part of my grocery and miscellaneous shopping there because this chain is so much cheaper than other retailers. But I know that God will honor my decision and will provide either the resources to pay more for my groceries, or the best sale prices at the other stores, or He will give me the blessing of more creativity to do my shopping without resorting to shopping at that particular chain.  I don't know if that will help your reader but I wanted to share my feelings on boycotting." ~ Terri


"Hooray for her for taking a stand. I started boycotting a major discount chain for political reasons a couple of years ago. It wasn't as painful as I thought! Are groceries a little more expensive? Yes, but I don't make as many impulse purchases. It's very convenient to go to one store for everything, but I actually find myself 'making do' or doing without more and I've discovered I don't really need a lot of things I thought I had to have. Staying out of the big chain store actually saves me money." ~ Cindy

 

Editor's Note: Thanks to these subscribers for taking the time to respond.

Sign up for Counting the Cost
a free twice-a-month email newsletter filled with ideas, insights and inspirations for living each day to the fullest. 

Email address:

Subscribe Unsubscribe

Google
 
Web     CountingtheCost.com

Home    Products and Resources     Speaking Engagements    Nancy's Itinerary  
Creative Frugality
     Talk It Out     Abundant Living    Readers' Input      Advertising Information      
National Creative Frugality Week
    Media Mentions and Publicity     Support This Site