...of Good Stewardship of Money and Time

CTC Readers' Poll:
Cable TV? 

 In the January 15, 2006 issue of the newsletter, we asked this question:

"Does your family have cable or satellite TV? And if you do because you feel it is important, does your family make other sacrifices to justify this expense?"

Editor's Note: We received a record number of responses to this question -- 
154 of them in all! Here is how the responses to the poll broke down:
87 of you said you DO NOT have cable or satellite TV (56%)

30 of you said you DO have cable or satellite TV (20%)

37 of you said you DO have cable or satellite TV, but only have the most basic package (24%)

We did not have room to list all the comments we received , but here are a few of the most memorable:

"Yes, we have satellite TV.  It is my husband’s chief source of entertainment in the evenings.  We don’t rent videos or DVDs or have any of those game systems and I haven’t been to the movie theater in years, so we don’t really spend money on other forms of entertainment.  I like to read or crochet or surf the web or cook, so the TV isn’t even turned on if my husband isn’t home (he travels with his job).  But I don’t have any trouble justifying the expense because he enjoys watching – and he watches pretty wholesome stuff – the History Channel, Food Network, HGTV, sports, etc.  We don’t subscribe to any of the premium channels (I don’t think I’m old enough to watch most of that stuff!)" ~ Cindy

 
"No, we do not have cable tv.  We had it many years ago for approx. 6 months.  In that time I noticed that we no longer needed to go to the library, because no one was reading.  I noticed that at the end of 6 months there were many jobs around the house that hadn't gotten done, because everyone was in front of the tv.  I noticed that we gained weight and had gotten lazy.  So no, even though our children are grown and gone we do not have cable and most likely never will." ~ Sandy


"Our family subscribes to digital cable.  As homeschoolers, we find a wealth of quality educational programming on the cable market that makes it worth the expense.  Because we have a DVR, we are not slaves to the schedule of these programs, and can pause and rewind them to discuss points or review information.  We watch very little network television, but find many of the channels available on cable worth the expense. We don't sacrifice other things to justify this expense.  If it came down to a choice, our cable connection would be among the first things to eliminate in our household." ~ DB

"We do have cable TV and consider ourselves frugal. I would love to cancel my subscription to it. However, I would find it almost impossible to convince my husband and kids that we could live without it. I long for a simpler day when cable and cell phones did not exist!

We have had cable TV since it first came out and was not so expensive. They seem to have us hooked for good! We do not go out a lot to movies or buy other expensive entertainment so I justify the cost in terms of that." ~ Charisse, Frugal Mom in Ohio


"I for one do not pay for cable or satellite TV. Maybe when the day comes that I can subscribe to the channels I want and not get other channels I don’t want with it, I may. But otherwise it is too expensive a resource for just something to do. There is nothing on TV that isn't available at the library, video store, online, or at home. I enjoy a few shows on the local networks, but I can only watch one channel at a time, and even at that, I watch far more 'junk' than I feel I should. So, now I do not and probably never will pay for extra channels." ~ PK

"We do not have cable TV or satellite TV.  I have six kids and I realized that my DH and I were always stressed in the evening (dinner, homework, kid's activities and then there were shows we wanted to watch on TV).  We decided to get rid of the satellite connection and only watch movies (from our personal collection) on Saturday evening.  Saturday evening we make special as family movie night.  Our evenings are more focused on family meals and helping our kid's with homework and are much more peaceful.  Our children no longer can watch worthless cartoons and shows with lots of commercials.  This was difficult at first because our lives were so centered around what was on TV.  We had alot of: what do I do with my spare time?  Now we spend more time as a family.  The kids play together.  Instead of whining about wanting new toys seen on TV; they actually play with the toys they already have.  They color and read and are much more creative and happy.  Getting rid of the satellite hookup was good for my family and my finances." ~ Sharlene

"I don't fit 'typical American' for many reasons, the first being that I am Canadian! :) We don't even have TV in our home. I have six children and want them to develop without TV. Watching the occasional DVD on our computer is more than enough 'watching.'  I want them to be 'doing'!" ~ Esther


"I personally am not much of a TV watcher but husband and daughter are! I have learned to go with their 'visual' learning habits and honor them. Because we homeschool, History Channel, Discovery Channel and A&E (all within suitability) all are great learning tools for my visually-oriented daughter and husband. I could live without cable but my husband sees it as a much needed expense. It's not worth arguing over!" ~ Colleen in GA

"I have satellite TV.  In many somewhat isolated parts of southern New Mexico and surely as well in the other western states, there is only 1 'local' channel, from a town 75 miles away, that comes in quite poorly to my TV, and just barely poorly.  Please consider geographic circumstances before you judge all 85% of us with paid television services as being extravagant in this spending choice.  Of course there are other things I would prefer to spend the satellite subscription money on.  But the amount of my monthly satellite bill would hardly cover even one day trip per month of travel to and entertainment in another town, or the cost of several magazine subscriptions to keep up with all sides of the world's goings-on, or compare to the time and effort that it would take to find daily entertainment and world news information on the Internet." ~ Nikki


"Although I am based in the U.K I felt I had to respond to your your question about Satellite TV, and warn others of my experience. I came to the Lord after I was married, and sadly my husband remains an unbeliever, although through God's amazing grace we generally get along fine. One of the single biggest mistakes I have made as a Christian is allowing Satellite TV into my home, giving in to just the type of social pressures you mention in your question. This costs us £30 a month, plus the TV license of about £130 per year, plus electric. The company also wanted about £9 each month for a maintenance contract on the equipment, which I refused. This is a lot of money- I don't know exactly but about 900 plus US dollars each year! What started as a luxury has become a 'necessity'  to my husband and children, who spend many hours viewing. My husband watches the sports channels constantly and as a result often spends his evening in a different room from the rest of the family. The overwhelming influence of the godlessness on many of the children's and teen programs mean that as a parent you have to be really vigilant and constantly on guard against it. The nature programs promote evolution, the sitcoms promote loose morality etc. There are a few good programs, but it takes real effort to police viewing and cope with the arguments that 'everyone else is allowed to watch it'!. In addition the company we are with have 'freeview' adult channels, which I had to have removed. I also use the parental controls to full effect.
 I agreed to  get Satellite TV naively, and did not seek the Lord's counsel as I should have done. I now cannot get my husbands agreement to cancel, which has caused friction. I am a stay-at-home Mum, and my husband has made it absolutely clear that he would expect me to work to pay for certain things, like Satellite TV, rather than do without if we ever became short of money.  I feel that I have allowed ungodly negative influences into my home, and the money spent is an utter waste. Overall Satellite TV has had a detrimental effect on my family life. Given that we are called to a separated life and to 'keeping oneself from being polluted by the world' (James 1:27),  I would caution any believer considering getting Cable or Satellite to do so very prayerfully, with much discernment and guidance from the Lord, and be certain that the rules are agreed by both partners beforehand. I have had to seek forgiveness from the Lord for this decision, and Satellite TV has been a snare and a stumbling block to me and my family. I would therefore want to warn anyone who is serious about honoring the Lord in their lives to be really careful. If you haven't got it - don't get it !!!" ~ Anonymous

Editor's Note: Thanks to all our readers who took time to write, even though we only had room to post these few.

Sign up for Counting the Cost
a free twice-a-month email newsletter filled with ideas, insights and inspirations for living each day to the fullest. 

Email address:

Subscribe Unsubscribe

Google
 
Web     CountingtheCost.com

Home    Products and Resources     Speaking Engagements    Nancy's Itinerary  
Creative Frugality
     Talk It Out     Abundant Living    Readers' Input      Advertising Information      
National Creative Frugality Week
    Media Mentions and Publicity     Support This Site